This Domino's sits right on York Road, one of those roads where you always seem to end up no matter what part of New Oxford you are coming from. It is easy to find, easy to get in and out of, and that matters more than people give it credit for. Order ahead and you will barely have to slow down.
Carryout is fast here. If a hot pizza waiting at the counter sounds better than waiting on a delivery, this is the right call, and plenty of people in the area have figured that out already. The delivery range covers a solid stretch of the county, so staying on the couch is just as good an option. Either way, the pizza shows up right.
There is something to be said for a place where the staff actually knows what they are doing and keeps things moving on a Friday night. The menu covers the basics and then some, from classic pepperoni to whatever combination you have been building in your head all week. New Oxford pizza delivery does not get more straightforward than this.