This Domino's sits right on West Ave, which puts it in easy reach of a lot of the west side of Canandaigua. People coming from the lake area or heading toward the commercial strip on that side of town pass this location constantly. It makes sense as a pickup spot, not just because of where it is, but because parking is easy and you are in and out without a hassle.
Canandaigua pizza delivery has to move, and this store does. Order placed, pizza at your door. The team here runs a tight operation, and the times are consistent whether it is a Tuesday night or a Friday with everyone ordering at once.
Some places earn repeat business and some places just exist. This one earns it. Families in the area have made it part of the routine, the same way you have a gas station you always go to or a grocery run that goes the same route every week. The menu covers enough ground that people are not compromising every time they order, and the quality holds up visit after visit, which is really what keeps people coming back to a place like this.